The 25 Best Secret Santa Gifts To Bring To Your Secret Santa Gift Exchange!

The most difficult decision around the holidays may be having to find gifts for Secret Santa parties. Secret Santa ideas don’t need much imagination since you already know what kind of Secret Santa gifts you will be giving and receiving. Sometimes people can go overboard and out of your budget with their Secret Santa gift exchange requests. If that is the case, you need to either get a gift that is similar to the item they want or hunt for a great deal to purchase the exact item they listed. We at Tellinga can help you find what kind of card, travel mug, or face mask your giftee writes down on their list while making sure it doesn't break the bank!

1. Tellinga

Try sending a series of cards as Secret Santa gifts if your assigned person has a “gift card” on their list. Tellinga is a startup based in Houston, TX that makes customized, story-telling cards. In order to make your gift special for your Secret Santa gift exchange, purchase your snail mail in a chain of deliveries.

If you just want to drop a hint to your co-worker or friend about who their Secret Santa is, sign up for the one week story length option. Tellinga will deliver one personalized Secret Santa card a day for a week. We will illustrate a three-part story of your choice so that your giftee can grow in anticipation leading up they find out who their Secret Santa gifter is!

If you decide that this is too much work, go ahead and order a gift card from us and let your Secret Santa partner choose who to send their story to. Sometimes the best gifts are the ones people get to choose for themselves.

2. Fresh Darlings Gift Set

When looking for Secret Santa gift ideas for your mom, try this complete spa kit from Fresh Darlings. You’ll receive all the brownie points for this one! This Secret Santa gift exchange will be a memorable one because your mom will appreciate that you listened to all of those times she “hinted” of needing a new face care routine.

3. Kiehl's Creme de Corps

This 8.4 oz. bottle of moisturizer is one of the fancy ideas for Secret Santa gifts. Choose a body moisturizer to help your giftee protect their skin during the cold winter, if you’re not in Texas, that is. Kiehl’s brand lotion can be found in Nordstrom and you have the option of ordering a 16 oz. bottle with a pump. Pair this lotion with a holiday card, from Tellinga if you choose, and you’ll have awesome gifts for Secret Santa!

4. Boska Holland Partyclette Melting Pan

Boska Holland Partyclette Melting Pan

CHEESE! This is one of the Secret Santa gift ideas that your giftee will thank you for. Simply add slices of any type of cheese and watch it slowly melt over a flame. After the cheese is completely melted, you can pour the cheese directly from the pan. This is one of the best Secret Santa gifts under $30 that your gift exchange partner will use for many meals to come.

5. Rolling Stones Paint It Bright Sock

Rolling Stones happy socks are fun ideas for Secret Santa gifts. They come in a number of assorted colors and patterns. Try snooping around to find out what your giftee’s favorite colors are so you can choose the pattern they’ll enjoy the most. These socks are the perfect Secret Santa gift ideas for coworkers.

6. GlamGlow Selfie-Approved Mask Set

The GlamGlow mask is perfect for your YouTuber niece if you have her as a Secret Santa gift exchange partner. The mask is applied to your face then you take it off minutes later and it leaves a foamy residue and fewer scars and acne than before. This mask is one of the self-care gifts for Secret Santa that can help boost the self-esteem of your camera-loving gift exchange partner.

7. Elago 3-in-1 Charging Hub

The Elago 3-in-1 Charging Hubb is one of the best Secret Santa gifts under $30 you could think of. Making this one of your Secret Santa gift ideas will show that you are thoughtful and know the needs of your giftee. This is only, of course, for those with Apple products. This charging hub can charge iPhones, AirPods, and Apple watches at the same time. Throw in a charging cord if you are feeling generous because it isn’t included.

8. Agate Stone Coasters

These beautiful agate stone coasters are one of the more practical, yet sophisticated ideas for Secret Santa gifts. This gift is sure to charm your friends at the Secret Santa gift exchange. Be sure to give these to someone who despises water rings on their dining room table. They will love this handy and decorative gift!

9. Rokono Bass + Mini Speaker

This compact, mini speaker carries a lot of bass and is compatible with several Bluetooth entertainment devices. Hook this up to both Android and iPhones, laptops, tablets, and iPads. This is easily one of the best Secret Santa gifts under $30.00. Whoever thinks the higher the price, the higher the quality, may have missed out on one of the best Secret Santa gifts ever. Bluetooth speakers are functional gifts for Secret Santa because you can use them during the party or while unwinding when the party is over.

10. Beer Mustard Trio

Beer Mustards are unconventional and funny Secret Santa gifts to bring to your Secret Santa gift exchange party. This homemade recipe comes from Oregon. The creators of the beer-infused mustard brand have concocted mustards that have Hefeweizen, stout beer, and chipotle. These mixtures will be one of the most unexpected and best Secret Santa gifts at your party.

11. 100 Things To Do Scratch Off Poster

This scratch-off poster is one of the truly unconventional Secret Santa gift ideas. If your gift exchange partner opens the gift, they might think of a giant lottery ticket. However, these posters can be adventurous gifts for Secret Santa and your giftee will appreciate the surprises awaiting them.

12. Cards Against Humanity

Cards Against Humanity is a card game that will liven the dullest parties. These cards are funny Secret Santa gifts because they are on the pricier side of gifts for Secret Santa. Some may not want to spend money on these, but if you decide to purchase the game, encourage your giftee to open it and share the game with the rest of the party. Your Secret Santa gift exchange peers will know that it was worth the money.

13. Contigo Autoseal Insulated Travel Mug

This travel mug is a perfect option if you are thinking of Secret Santa gift ideas for coworkers. It’s an ideal gift for coworkers who tend to come into the office late every day because they were waiting in line at their favorite coffee shop. Ordering coffee grounds or Keurig cups are perfect ideas for Secret Santa gifts if you want to give your giftee something extra.

14. Himalayan Glow Salt Lamp

These popular Himalayan salt lamps are good Secret Santa gifts for your bohemian coworker who habitually cleanses the air in their living space. These salt lamps are great accessories to coffee tables, end tables, and foyer tables because they provide a subtle glow that can warm up the vibe in any room. These lamps are both thoughtful and pleasant gifts for Secret Santa.

15. SipWell Extra Long Stainless Steel Drinking Straws

Try including these SipWell Extra Long Stainless Steel Drinking Straws in your Secret Santa ideas. These straws are eco-friendly, washable, and come with handy scrub brushes. The stainless steel drinking straws are ideal Secret Santa gift ideas for coworkers who tend to use up all of the supply of straws in the office. Gift these to them and you’ll never have to endure that problem again!

16. Old Fashioned Carry-On Cocktail Kit

This Old Fashioned Carry-On Cocktail Kit is one of the best Secret Santa gifts because it is compact and you can sneak it on the plane or in the movie theater. This goes on the list of best Secret Santa gifts under $30 because it’s a sophisticated way of drinking a cocktail. The kit comes with a list of the perfect measurements. You can test your mixology skills on the go, but drink safely!

17. One Question a Day Journal

These journals are awesome Secret Santa ideas for those who love to capture their thoughts and aspirations. This journal poses one thought-provoking question a day that will encourage chosen writers to explore the thoughts they might have suppressed or maybe never even thought of before. These Secret Santa gifts will show that you care about the perspectives and mental health of your Secret Santa gift exchange partner.

18. Felt Letter Board

These trendy felt letter boards are good Secret Santa gifts that will have your gift exchange partner wanting more Secret Santa gifts from you. These can be used as directive signs or just to capture your feelings of the day. Use these felt letter boards to advertise menu items, encourage your students, or give directions. Whichever way the board is used, it’ll be a nice addition to your giftee’s home collection. Whichever way the board is used, it’ll be a nice addition to your giftee’s home collection.

19. The Office Mug

World’s Best Boss is a title not to be given lightly. This ode to the hit show, The Office, is the most ironic of Secret Santa ideas you might bring to your holiday party. If you know your giftee is a fan of the show, this mug could be one of the funny Secret Santa gifts at the party because they might take a walk down memory lane with you to discuss their favorite episodes!

20. OXO Good Grips Shatterproof French Press

This shatterproof French press Secret Santa gift ideas for coworkers who love to travel, but like authentically fresh coffee in every sip. This French press from OXO is one of the best Secret Santa gifts you can buy because of how versatile it is. The filter inside is made of silicone and the entire French press is dishwasher safe, making it easy to be cleaned.

21. Mario Badescu Azulene Calming Mask

The Azulene Calming Mask is one of the fanciest Secret Santa ideas that is useful for nighttime facial treatments. Anyone who cares about making their skin as smooth and clear as possible will rank this calming mask among the most ideal Secret Santa gifts.

22. Pizza Rescue Kit

If you get the Pizza Rescue Kit, your giftee will think it is one of the funny Secret Santa gifts at the party. This the best out of all the Secret Santa gifts you could give to a college student or someone who may work at a hospital and survives on cafeteria food. Sprinkle a little Italian seasoning, crushed pepper, or truffle salt to liven up a dull slice of pizza.

23. La Roma Microwave Popcorn Popper

The La Roma Microwave Popcorn Popper is one of the best Secret Santa gifts for those whole love homemade treats. This popcorn popper is one of the easiest to navigate. To make the popcorn, measure a reasonable amount of seeds in the provided cap for the kettle; dump the seeds into the bowl; cover the kettle with the cap; and place a slice of butter on top. Place the popcorn popper in the microwave and watch the magic unfold! This is easily one of the most creative Secret Santa gifts at your party.

24. PopSockets Grip

PopSockets are good Secret Santa gifts because they are affordable and come in a variety of designs. These can match the color of your phone or, if you want to make a statement, you can choose patterned and animated PopSockets. You can also add a picture of your favorite person or your favorite food. These Secret Santa gifts are both fun and practical. They make a fun sound when pulled out, then pushed back in and are great trinkets to use for people who fidget. If you get tired of holding your phone, the PopSocket makes for an excellent phone stand.

25. "Salt Fat Acid Heat" Cookbook

Salt Fat Acid Heat, a popular cookbook turned Netflix special, showcases ways to use the key four elements of professional cuisine. Good Secret Santa gifts such as this one is a good addition to any home. Your Secret Santa gift exchange partner will learn about the endless possibilities of cooking with the four elements form a professional chef!


Go above and beyond for your Secret Santa gift exchange parties this year. There are funny miniature gifts, electronics, and practical gifts that can start a conversation and make your party's environment more vibrant. Pair your Secret Santa gift with a card to let your giftee know how much you appreciate them. If you would like 100% custom, hand-illustrated cards for your Secret Santa exchange partner, order from Tellinga! We place a Tellinga stamp on your card and mail it to your chosen location. Then, we will post digital versions of your epistolary in the “Download Your Story” section of our site and email you a copy too. We love what we do, so choose us and have your story told today. You'll be the envy of your Secret Santa gift exchange party!

Visit the following articles to find more ideas for Secret Santa exchange party gifts:

#secretsanta #secretsantagifts #giftsforsecretsanta #secretsantagiftideas #ideasforsecretsantagifts #secretsantaideas #bestsecretsantagifts #goodsecretsantagifts #funnysecretsantagifts #secretsantagiftideasforcoworkers #bestsecretsantagiftsunder30 #secretsantagiftexchange

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
  • Twitter
  • YouTube
  • TikTok

Copyright © 2020 Tellinga, LLC. ® All rights reserved.

Houston, TX